Reviews & Features

What the Concert for George Film Adds to Tom Petty’s “I Need You”

The Concert for George exists as a film and as a recording listeners can play for the music. “I Need You” makes that difference easy to hear and see. Tom Petty gives the vocal a clear sense of feeling, and the camera lets people look at the rest of an ensemble that has work to do beneath it.

Follow the song once as a sequence of sounds and then return to the video. The lead voice keeps its place across both, while the onstage relationships become much easier to see in the film. Each view offers a way to hear one of Harrison’s early songs in a room he never stood in that evening.

The Concert for George was held at the Royal Albert Hall on November 29, 2002. Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers performed “I Need You,” and the film preserves the larger group around them. The Beatles recording gives the lead vocal and guitar parts a much earlier point of comparison.

The audience can carry both impressions back to the original record.

The Beatles version has its own visual associations, most of which the Royal Albert Hall film lets you set aside for a few minutes. Compare what each recording supplies when you take the listening experience back to the original melody.