Reviews & Features

Cynthia Erivo Made Rock Hall Wait for Phil Collins’ Famous Drum Fill

By the time Travis Barker played the drum fill in “In the Air Tonight,” the audience at the Peacock Theater had been waiting for it. Most listeners know the passage by heart. Cynthia Erivo still found space in the opening to let the suspense build while Barker sat behind the kit.

Erivo and Barker were there to honor Phil Collins at the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame on November 14. Barker had inducted Collins earlier in the program and talked about how much that famous drum entrance had meant to him as a young musician. He then had to play it in the same room as the man who made it famous.

Collins came onstage to accept the honor as a solo artist. Genesis had already entered the Hall in 2010. He spoke about having wanted to play drums since childhood. That made the choice of a tribute built around the long wait for a drummer to come forward particularly apt.

Erivo’s role is the part a short clip can lose. She moves through the early lines slowly enough that the voice remains the point of focus. The longer she can hold that attention on her own, the bigger the change feels when the drums arrive.

Barker has a recognizable style of his own as the drummer in Blink-182. Here the song asks him to sit through the quiet part and hit a familiar entrance at the right moment. The camera eventually gives him all the attention, and the minutes that come before it belong to Erivo.

The full audience recording lets you follow the timing. If you already know the Collins version, it is worth starting from the first line before jumping to the fill. The way Erivo paces the song is what makes the payoff feel earned.

The same entrance from the room

A second audience recording from the Peacock Theater gives another view of the musicians. Knowing the fill is coming can draw your eye toward Barker, but this angle makes it easier to follow the exchange between the singer and the drummer as the arrangement opens up.

Go back to the 1981 recording

The original Collins video shows how much of the song is already working before the drum entrance. Its sparseness gives the later sound somewhere to go. The tribute kept that basic idea and gave it to two performers. One voice holds the room, then a drummer changes the scale of the song.