‘American Idol’ Season 23 Finale Sees Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Carrie Underwood Take the Stage Together for a Show-Stopping Performance

Season 23 of American Idol came to an emotional and unforgettable conclusion, offering viewers powerful performances, surprises, and one of the most talked-about finales in recent memory. As the three finalists—John Foster, Breanna Nix, and Jamal Roberts—prepared to battle for the title, a highlight of the night came when the judging trio themselves took the stage. Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and first-time judge Carrie Underwood teamed up for a special performance that brought the crowd to its feet.

Their rendition of “Stuck On You,” originally released by Richie in 1984, was a poignant reminder of the talent seated at the judging panel. Richie opened the number with smooth, familiar vocals before Underwood’s soaring voice joined in, followed by Bryan’s warm harmony. Together, they delivered a seamless and heartfelt performance that not only showcased their individual gifts but their chemistry as a trio. The moment marked one of the rare times judges performed together live, making it a standout finale memory.

Each of the judges brought their own storied musical background to the performance. Richie, with decades of hits and accolades, brought classic soul to the mix. Underwood, still hailed as one of Idol’s greatest success stories, delivered grace and vocal power. Bryan, the country superstar and seasoned live performer, added warmth and charm to the set. Their voices blended naturally, reinforcing why each of them commands a place on that stage.

While the song itself was soft and intimate, the emotions behind the performance ran deep. Fans were quick to praise the judges not just for stepping out of their typical roles but for sharing a moment that felt genuine and nostalgic. Social media lit up with clips and reactions, hailing the performance as one of the most “real” and “heartfelt” moments of the night, reminding everyone of the music that brought them all together in the first place.

Though Carrie Underwood’s presence was fresh to the judging panel this season, her performance reflected a veteran’s ease. Having taken over Katy Perry’s seat after a seven-season run, Underwood brought not just her Idol roots but also a unique perspective as someone who once stood on the other side of the stage. Her vulnerability and honesty, both in judging and performing, were praised by many throughout the season.

Despite the evening’s celebratory tone, not everything unfolded without debate. Some viewers speculated about Underwood’s reaction during Roberts’ win announcement, calling it distant or forced. While others defended her demeanor as overwhelmed or emotional, the moment added fuel to ongoing discussions about whether she would return for Season 24. Underwood has not made a definitive statement on her future with the show.

Behind the scenes, producers remain hopeful about the current judging trio. According to showrunner Megan Michaels Wolflick, submissions for next season are already flooding in, and the team feels optimistic about the show’s momentum. Whether Underwood decides to stay or not, the network is expected to finalize decisions soon as excitement builds for the next chapter.

Jamal Roberts’ crowning moment was powerful and deeply symbolic. As the first Black male winner since Ruben Studdard in 2003, Roberts captured hearts across the country with his raw, soulful voice and humble personality. His performance of “Her Heart” was widely viewed as the moment he clinched the competition, drawing standing ovations and a wave of support from fans and former Idol winners alike.

Throughout the season, Roberts consistently delivered emotional performances that resonated with both viewers and judges. His ability to personalize lyrics and sing with conviction became his trademark. From gospel numbers to contemporary ballads, Roberts approached each song with sincerity and purpose, proving that his artistry goes beyond just vocal ability.

The finale also featured other musical moments, including surprise appearances from Jessica Simpson, Patti LaBelle, and Jelly Roll. Simpson’s return to the spotlight sparked divided reactions, with fans both celebrating her comeback and criticizing parts of her performance. Nevertheless, her duet with finalist Josh King on “These Boots Are Made for Walkin’” brought a dose of nostalgia to the night.

As the curtain fell on Season 23, attention turned to what comes next for American Idol. With auditions for the next season already underway, questions remain about potential changes to the judging panel and overall format. Still, the success of this season—bolstered by performances like the judges’ “Stuck On You”—suggests the show’s core appeal remains as strong as ever.

In the end, the true standout wasn’t just the winner or the star guests—it was the authenticity that shined through. The judges’ willingness to perform together, the tears, the tension, and the triumph all came together to make the Season 23 finale one for the ages. As Jamal Roberts now begins his journey as an Idol winner, fans are left inspired, emotional, and already counting down to next season.